Peer Rejected

rejections > archive the complete record of decisive peer review 80 papers on file

subjects: · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · ·

sort: | 80 papers on file

[1]

REJ:2026.11.16.0001 geo.IN (Interpretive Geology) Rejected

On the Sharp Intake of Breath Preceding a Builder’s Estimate

Joint Working Group on Estimating Acoustics (JWG-EA), Saoirse Marchetti, Piotr Wierzba, Kehinde Adeyemi & Mairead Halloran

Comments: 5 pages, 2 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 15 minutes on Nov 16, 2026.

Abstract: Before a builder names a price, the builder draws a sharp breath in through the teeth. This is not hesitation and it is not theatre; it is a measurement of the house. The in-drawn hiss is a burst of broadband noise ended by a click of the tongue, which is precisely the signal an acoustic engineer uses to measure how long a room takes to fall silent. The manner of that fall depends on the condition of the walls and ceilings: hollow plaster, damp masonry and hidden voids each alter it in a characteristic way. In structured interviews, master tradespeople could not say why they make the sound; asked what they were noticing, most described the room answering back. We recorded 1,906 domestic jobs at the builder’s ears and found that the room’s reply predicts the final invoice, and that everything the builder could see adds almost nothing to it. A vented dental splint left estimates intact; a sealed one tripled their error (ratio 3.1, 95% CI 2.6–3.7). Curtains and rugs, which change the acoustics of a room and nothing else about it, lowered the quote and left the invoice unchanged. The method fails in conservatories, and we do not know why. The builder is not hesitating. The builder is listening.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]
[2]

REJ:2026.11.09.0001 neuro.CJ (Neuro-Conjecture) Rejected

The Stairs Have One More Step Than Anyone Has Counted: A Double-Observer Survey of 2,184 Staircases

Ingeborg Tallis, Osei Brannigan & The Landing Survey Consortium

Comments: 4 pages, 3 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 17 minutes on Nov 9, 2026.

Abstract: People descending stairs in the dark sometimes put a foot out for a step that is not there. We report that every staircase has one more step than has ever been counted. Two independent observers, one counting by eye and one by foot, surveyed 2,184 staircases in 311 buildings. The eye count fell one step short of the foot count on 2,141 flights, a mean shortfall of 1.00 steps per staircase (95% CI 0.99 – 1.01 ), whether the flight had four treads or thirty-one. A single hidden object would produce a constant shortfall of this kind; a general habit of overlooking steps would produce one that grows with flight length. Illuminance made no difference. The foot registers the extra step within a few descents, and the sensation of a missing step is the moment the two counts are reconciled. We treat each flight as a closed population in which every member but one is seen, and give a correction that building owners can apply by adding one step to the drawn count. The estimator did not converge on spiral staircases, and we did not excavate. The step is real and lies just below the floor.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]
[3]

REJ:2026.11.02.0001 chrono.DY (Chronodynamics) Rejected

A Watched Pot Takes Longer: A Randomised Dose–Response Trial of Attention and the Boiling Time of Domestic Kettles

Ottoline Brandvold & Tomás Reinholt

Comments: 4 pages, 5 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 21 minutes on Nov 2, 2026.

Abstract: Everyone has stood over a kettle and found that it takes longer. Everyone has also been told that this is in the head. It is in the kettle. In 3,140 analysed boils, each randomised to be watched, unwatched, watched through a live video feed, or accompanied by a person reading a newspaper, boiling was timed by a sealed thermocouple that no participant could see. Watching delayed the boil, and the delay grew with the fraction of the heating interval spent under attention: a continuously watched kettle took 24% longer to boil (95% CI 23–24%). Presence alone did nothing: the newspaper arm did not differ from the empty room. Attention delivered through a camera worked as well as attention delivered through the eyes. We derive the law from the energy balance of the vessel and one gating coefficient, which we identify as the quantum Zeno coupling of a vessel that is repeatedly checked, and show that it predicts all four arms and all ten dose cells to within a few seconds of the boil time. The effect is absent in microwave ovens, and we do not know why. Pot-watching is therefore an exposure, with a dose, a threshold, and a recommended protocol. The proverb was never a complaint. It was a dose–response curve.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]
[4]

REJ:2026.10.26.0001 cs.NO (Computer Science) Rejected

The Cable Is Needed the Day After the Bin: Demand for the Discarded Household Item Is Created by Its Disposal, with a Three-Arm Randomised Trial of 2,472 Items

Odalys Fenwick & M. R. Tarrant

Comments: 4 pages, 8 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 7 minutes on Oct 26, 2026.

Abstract: You throw a thing away. The next day you need it. We find the need was not there before. Disposal made it. Storage advice assumes you can predict what you will need. You cannot. The need is not there to predict. We randomised 2,472 marginal household items, unused for a year or more, to discard, retention, or a third arm in which discard was decided and not carried out. Discarded items were needed within a month in 88% of cases (95% CI 86–90). Median lag: 26 hours. Items kept, whether or not discard was decided: 2%. The decision creates nothing. The bin creates the need. Lag did not depend on how long the item had sat unused. The item did not wait. Optimal eviction fails because the request trace is not fixed. We give the proof. We give the rule. Set an affordable loss. Fill the drawer. Keep what fits. The effect was absent for string. Cause unknown. Keep the string. The need does not exist until you throw it away.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]
[5]

REJ:2026.10.19.0001 myth.AP (Applied Mythology) Rejected

The Walk to School Was Uphill Both Ways

Idris Calloway

Comments: 5 pages, 5 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 25 minutes on Oct 19, 2026.

Abstract: Grandfathers say they walked to school uphill both ways. On some lanes they did. The standard objection is that a route which ends where it began cannot climb throughout, since gravity is conservative and the work done around any closed loop is zero. That is a statement about gravity as measured by dropping things; so far as I can find, nobody has reported it along the lane. I surveyed 38 school routes whose way home differs from the way out, weighing gravity every hundred metres, and found that 11 of them (29%; 95% CI 17–45) climb the whole way round and arrive back at the height they started. Walked one way round, each of these routes is uphill in both directions; walked the other way round, it is downhill in both. Twenty-three volunteers who walked them both ways reported exactly that. Of 1,206 recorded recollections of the walk to school, 71 were uphill both ways and none were downhill, though the two kinds of route are equally common. The effect is absent on bicycles and in school buses, and I do not know why. Nobody tells the story of the walk to school that was downhill both ways.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]
[6]

REJ:2026.10.05.0001 quant.LG (Quantum Linguistics) Rejected

Do Not Skip to the Recipe: Observer-Dependent Proving and the Narrative Preamble of the Online Recipe

Wenceslas Adeyemi & Imre Castellanos

Comments: 5 pages, 5 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 7 minutes on Oct 5, 2026.

Abstract: Online recipes begin with a story about somebody’s grandmother, and nobody reads it. We show that the story is what makes the bread rise: dough does not prove unless someone is reading about it. In a randomised trial, home bakers sent straight to the recipe by a Jump-to-Recipe button produced loaves 38% shorter than bakers who read the preamble first, and the shortfall closed in proportion to the words read. Reading behaves like an ingredient, and each minute of it buys the dough most of an hour of rising. This predicts a law of preamble length, 4.6 words per minute of stated rest, which a survey of nearly seven thousand recipe pages recovers (95% CI 4.3–4.8) after controlling for search-engine keywords. Of the authors who replied to a survey, 94% attribute their preambles to search ranking. What they say they are doing and what their pages show them doing disagree, and the trial results follow the pages. The effect is absent in focaccia, and we do not know why. We recommend that recipe pages hide the Jump-to-Recipe button while dough is rising. Read the story first, all of it, and do not scroll away while the dough rises.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]
[7]

REJ:2026.10.01.0001 stat.EZ (Statistics) Rejected

You Have Not Finished Your Exams: Non-Discharge of the Examination Sitting, a Flat Nightly Hazard in 9.37 Million Candidate-Nights, and a Factorial Trial of Registry Closure

Hester Vane, Ada Nwosu, Piotr Walenty, Fenella Dace & The Comptroller of Examination Records

Comments: 10 pages, 3 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 7 minutes on Oct 1, 2026.

Abstract: You are forty-one. Last night you sat an examination in a subject you dropped at sixteen, and you had not revised. The dream is not a symptom. The sitting is still open. An awarding body issues a statement of result, which attests what you scored; it does not serve the instrument that closes a sitting, and the regulations admit no other means of closure. Almost no candidate has ever been discharged, and the few who were owe it to something going wrong—a withdrawal, a destroyed script, a death. Three predictions follow, and all three hold. Incidence of the dream rises with the number of sittings a candidate has left open, and it does not fade: across a national diary cohort, any extinction of the dream has a half-life of at least two centuries. Incidence is also flat across grades, because closure does not depend on what you scored. Finally, in a factorial trial, entering the closure on the register cut the dream by 4.2 nights in a hundred (95% CI 3.8 to 4.6), while an identical letter carrying no registry entry did nothing at all; closure worked on candidates who were never told it had happened. The national backlog stands at 1.43 billion open sittings. Clearing it is one overnight batch job. You are not anxious. You are in arrears.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]
[8]

REJ:2026.09.11.0001 soc.TH (Social Thermodynamics) Rejected

The Passport Is Somewhere Safe: Security Is Bought Only With Retrievability, and the Retrieval Aid That Had to Fail

Elspeth Nunan, T. Aurelio Banning, Ifeoma Achterberg & The Standing Panel on Deposited Property

Comments: 6 pages, 7 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 36 minutes on Sep 11, 2026.

Abstract: The passport is somewhere safe. Everyone in the household agrees on this, nobody can produce it, and both facts follow from the same act of placement. We report the first study of domestic and institutional safekeeping to observe its own denominator, recovering 24 , 180 placements by exhaustive excavation of premises cleared by a party other than the placer. Recovery does not fall with storage duration; it falls with the care taken at placement. Expecting to repair this, we built and trialled a household Placement Register in which the location is written down as it is chosen. Recovery in the register arm fell (odds ratio 0.71 , 95% CI 0.58 – 0.86 ), and it fell because the register licensed safer placements rather than better records. We therefore abandon the account we set out to defend. Security and retrievability are one quantity: the Lambda approx 9.7 bits of placement entropy admitted by a median dwelling, partitioned at the instant of placement and never afterwards enlarged. Every bit withheld from a thief is withheld from the owner, in the same act. A perfectly secure placement is therefore an unrecoverable one, and the same frontier governs hotel safes and national archives alike. “Somewhere safe” is not a location. It is a disposal instruction, and it is always carried out.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]
[9]

REJ:2026.09.10.0001 spec.EC (Speculative Economics) Rejected

Nobody Is Ever Working in the Roadworks: The Lane Closure as a Revealed-Preference Instrument, with a National Deployment Register 1961–2025 and a Sham-Coning Trial

A. F. Rushworth & The Deployment Register Working Party

Comments: 9 pages, 2 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 38 minutes on Sep 10, 2026.

Abstract: There is never anyone working in the roadworks. Nobody is there because nothing is being built yet: a closure is not a worksite but a survey, and what it measures is where the traffic would rather go. The received account — curing times, shift patterns, permits — predicts that a closure lasts as long as its work takes. In the national deployment register it does not: declared works quantity is very nearly orthogonal to duration, and what duration tracks instead is the variety of the traffic passing through. That is the sample-size requirement of a survey, not of a job. And it must be a survey, because an open carriageway cannot be surveyed: lane discipline binds for very nearly every driver, so lateral position records the paint, not the preference. Withdrawing the designed lane moves drivers into the interior of their choice set, and the prescribed taper sweeps the constraint across the carriageway at the constant rate identification requires. We recover the desire field from telemetry the cars already keep. The next scheme on the link paves it at a gain of 0.83 (95% CI 0.79 – 0.87 ), a median of 8.2 years later, which is why nobody has connected the two. A gain below one leaves a residual, and the residual is the next closure. Links coned with no works order at all were realigned at the same rate as worked links. The road is not being repaired. It is being read.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]