REJ:2026.10.19.0001 myth.AP (Applied Mythology) Rejected
The Walk to School Was Uphill Both Ways
Idris Calloway
Comments: 5 pages, 5 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 25 minutes on Oct 19, 2026.
Abstract: Grandfathers say they walked to school uphill both ways. On some lanes they did. The standard objection is that a route which ends where it began cannot climb throughout, since gravity is conservative and the work done around any closed loop is zero. That is a statement about gravity as measured by dropping things; so far as I can find, nobody has reported it along the lane. I surveyed 38 school routes whose way home differs from the way out, weighing gravity every hundred metres, and found that 11 of them (29%; 95% CI 17–45) climb the whole way round and arrive back at the height they started. Walked one way round, each of these routes is uphill in both directions; walked the other way round, it is downhill in both. Twenty-three volunteers who walked them both ways reported exactly that. Of 1,206 recorded recollections of the walk to school, 71 were uphill both ways and none were downhill, though the two kinds of route are equally common. The effect is absent on bicycles and in school buses, and I do not know why. Nobody tells the story of the walk to school that was downhill both ways.