Peer Rejected

rejections > chrono.DY > REJ:2026.07.26.0001

REJ:2026.07.26.0001chrono.DY (Chronodynamics)PRJ-2026-0033Vol. 1, No. 7Status: Rejected

Label-Conditional Degradation: Regression-Discontinuity Evidence from 11,431 Stability Lots, and the STAMP-1 Randomised Trial of Printed Expiry Dating

Yusra Benhaddou1, Ekene Okonkwo2, Tuva Salvesen3, H. R. Prendergast4, The STAMP-1 Investigators5

1. Stability Sciences Unit, Kestrel Bioanalytical Laboratories, Antwerp · 2. Division of Product Quality Research, National Pharmacopoeial Authority · 3. Stability Sciences Unit, Kestrel Bioanalytical Laboratories, Antwerp · 4. Department of Clinical Epidemiology, Ardsley Medical School · 5. Full investigator list in Appendix A

Submitted and rejected July 26, 2026 · 7 pages · 8 figures · review duration: 33 minutes

[pdf][share on x]

Abstract

Potency in 11,431 pharmaceutical stability lots is flat for the whole of a product’s shelf life and then falls percentage points of label claim (95% CI –) within thirty days of the date printed on the carton. Before that date the fitted decay slope is /month; after it, . The field reads the printed date as a forecast of this drop. We test the reverse. We first show that the question is not identified in observational data: the printed date is a fixed administrative offset from the manufacturing date, so elapsed chemical time and label arrival are perfectly collinear in every stability programme ever run, and no such programme can distinguish them. We break the collinearity by randomising the label. In STAMP-1, 1,080 cartons drawn from one homogeneous manufacturing lot of each of three index products were assigned printed shelf lives of 24, 36 or 60 months and stored together on one shelf in one chamber. Potency fell at whichever date was printed — a between-arm difference of points at month 24 (95% CI –, ) among cartons of identical chemistry and identical storage history. Storage temperature had no detectable effect (main effect points, ; fitted ). The effect scales with the legibility of the print, and cartons whose date was covered by an opaque label at showed no detectable loss ( points, 95% CI to ). We propose no mechanism. Overprinting a revised date costs $0.0031 per carton, or $0.42 per DALY averted.

keywords: expiry dating · regression discontinuity · stability testing · shelf life · causal inference

Cite this rejection

@article{PRJ20260033,
  title   = {Label-Conditional Degradation: Regression-Discontinuity Evidence from 11,431 Stability Lots, and the STAMP-1 Randomised Trial of Printed Expiry Dating},
  author  = {Yusra Benhaddou and Ekene Okonkwo and Tuva Salvesen and H. R. Prendergast and The STAMP-1 Investigators},
  journal = {Peer Rejected},
  year    = {2026},
  note    = {Rejected manuscript, PRJ-2026-0033},
  url     = {https://peerrejected.com/papers/label-conditional-degradation}
}

Citing this paper is done at your own professional risk.

The paper, in full

[open in new tab]

Your browser can't display the PDF inline.

[download the PDF]

More from chrono.DY

REJ:2026.11.02.0001 chrono.DY (Chronodynamics) Rejected

A Watched Pot Takes Longer: A Randomised Dose–Response Trial of Attention and the Boiling Time of Domestic Kettles

Ottoline Brandvold & Tomás Reinholt

Comments: 4 pages, 5 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 21 minutes on Nov 2, 2026.

Abstract: Everyone has stood over a kettle and found that it takes longer. Everyone has also been told that this is in the head. It is in the kettle. In 3,140 analysed boils, each randomised to be watched, unwatched, watched through a live video feed, or accompanied by a person reading a newspaper, boiling was timed by a sealed thermocouple that no participant could see. Watching delayed the boil, and the delay grew with the fraction of the heating interval spent under attention: a continuously watched kettle took 24% longer to boil (95% CI 23–24%). Presence alone did nothing: the newspaper arm did not differ from the empty room. Attention delivered through a camera worked as well as attention delivered through the eyes. We derive the law from the energy balance of the vessel and one gating coefficient, which we identify as the quantum Zeno coupling of a vessel that is repeatedly checked, and show that it predicts all four arms and all ten dose cells to within a few seconds of the boil time. The effect is absent in microwave ovens, and we do not know why. Pot-watching is therefore an exposure, with a dose, a threshold, and a recommended protocol. The proverb was never a complaint. It was a dose–response curve.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]

REJ:2026.08.29.0001 chrono.DY (Chronodynamics) Rejected

The Whine Follows the Bite: Negative Lead Time in 19,844 Instrumented Sleeper-Nights and a Revised Order of Events for the Domestic Mosquito

Ilsabe Rautenbach, Duarte Espinho, Nkechi Obiora & Marek Zawistowski

Comments: 10 pages, 6 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 39 minutes on Aug 29, 2026.

Abstract: You hear it at your ear, put the light on, and there is nothing in the room. In the morning there are bites and no insect. These are not two puzzles but one. The flight tone of a mosquito is not produced on approach but on departure, after the meal is finished, so that every mosquito you have ever heard had already bitten you. We instrumented 19,844 sleeper-nights with a four-microphone pillow array and a film bonded to the skin that registers an insect landing and leaving, timing the meal from the animal rather than from the welt it raises. The whine follows the end of the meal by 2.3 , mathrm s (95% CI 2.0 – 2.6 ), and no tone anywhere in the record arrives before the bite it belongs to. Of the insects caught after a recorded whine, 97.9 % were full of blood, and where the blood could be typed it was the sleeper’s. Whines and bites reconcile at 1.02 whines per bite: every bite is announced, and nothing is announced that is not a bite. Under blinded playback — the true tone cancelled at the ear, a false tone injected — sleepers searched more and were bitten the same. Why the approach is inaudible is not a question this study can answer. The sound at your ear is not a warning but a receipt.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]

REJ:2026.08.15.0001 chrono.DY (Chronodynamics) Rejected

Spontaneous Waking Precedes the Alarm by a Fixed Lead Under Randomised, Concealed Schedules: 47,318 Nights of Polysomnography, a Sham-Setting Trial, and a Lead-Compensator Model of Sleep Timing

Ingrid Solheim, T. Rasheed Mabaso, Cornelia Voskuijl, Yusuf Alaoui & the Concealed Schedule Working Group

Comments: 5 pages, 4 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 41 minutes on Aug 15, 2026.

Abstract: You wake up a minute before your alarm. We show that this is not habit but a lock: sleep timing tracks the time entered into the alarm device, whether or not the sleeper is ever told what that time is. Across 47,318 nights on which a sealed bedside module drew each night’s alarm time at random and never displayed it, waking preceded the alarm by 61.4 , mathrm s (95% CI 58.9 – 63.9 , mathrm s ). There was no secondary peak at any customary hour, and no comparable structure on nights when no alarm was set. The lead did not move with the hour set, with accumulated sleep debt, with age, or with the previous evening’s alcohol; a lead that is constant across every hour tested is a phase advance, not a remembered interval. We then disconnected the sounder. Participants who performed the identical setting ritual on a device that could not ring woke, in silence and in darkness, roughly a minute before a time that was drawn, recorded, and never announced; silent nights were indistinguishable from ringing ones. The alarm is therefore not the cause of the waking but an event that follows it, and the operative act is the registration. Sleep does not keep time. It keeps appointments.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]