Peer Rejected

rejections > neuro.CJ > REJ:2026.07.10.0001

REJ:2026.07.10.0001neuro.CJ (Neuro-Conjecture)PRJ-2026-0016Vol. 2, No. 7DOI 10.5555/prj.2026.the-car-park-is-an-oceanStatus: Rejected

The Car Park Is an Ocean: A Navigational Reclassification of the Multi-Storey Structure, with a Randomized Trial of Instrument-Free Wayfinding

Moana R. Ellingham-Teiva1, Desmond K. Whitlock2, Priya S. Vanterpool-Okafor3

1. Ōpaki School of Terrestrial Voyaging · 2. Department of Misplaced Cognition, Halloran University · 3. Centre for Post-Payment Amnesia Studies, Institute for Retail Oceanography

Submitted and rejected July 10, 2026 · 8 pages · 7 figures · review duration: 18 minutes

[pdf][share on x]

Abstract

Everyone has lost a car in a multi-storey car park, and everyone has drawn the same two conclusions: the building is badly designed, and their memory is going. We show that both conclusions are wrong, and that the correct conclusion is considerably worse. Surveying five environments for stable distinguishable features—the fixed, tell-apart-able landmarks that human navigation actually runs on—we find that a multi-storey car park offers usable features per hectare, fewer than the Sahara () and fewer than the open Pacific (). By the only metric that matters to a navigator, the car park is not a building. It is an ocean, and an unusually bare one. This reclassification explains the memory problem: in a longitudinal study of 64 drivers we find that recall of one’s parking level decays with a half-life of 41 minutes and is destroyed outright by the act of paying, while the same participants recall where they sat in a caf\’e at . Nothing is being forgotten; below a measurable landmark floor the brain files each visit as a duplicate of the last, so that every visit to a car park is a first visit. Memory being unavailable in principle, the environment must be navigated instead—and the appropriate technology has existed for three thousand years. In a randomized trial (), participants given six weeks of instrument-free wayfinding training adapted from Pacific practice—reading trolley drift as current, tire-sheen as swell, pigeon transects as land-finding birds, and the ceiling’s sprinkler grid as a star compass—located their vehicles faster than smartphone users and faster than controls, with zero failures. The problem was never your memory. We keep issuing sailors a floor plan.

keywords: wayfinding · multi-storey car park · spatial memory · navigational entropy · trolley drift · hippocampal deduplication

Cite this rejection

@article{PRJ20260016,
  title   = {The Car Park Is an Ocean: A Navigational Reclassification of the Multi-Storey Structure, with a Randomized Trial of Instrument-Free Wayfinding},
  author  = {Moana R. Ellingham-Teiva and Desmond K. Whitlock and Priya S. Vanterpool-Okafor},
  journal = {Peer Rejected},
  year    = {2026},
  note    = {Rejected manuscript, PRJ-2026-0016},
  url     = {https://peerrejected.com/papers/the-car-park-is-an-ocean}
}

Citing this paper is done at your own professional risk.

The paper, in full

[open in new tab]

Your browser can't display the PDF inline.

[download the PDF]

More from neuro.CJ

REJ:2026.11.09.0001 neuro.CJ (Neuro-Conjecture) Rejected

The Stairs Have One More Step Than Anyone Has Counted: A Double-Observer Survey of 2,184 Staircases

Ingeborg Tallis, Osei Brannigan & The Landing Survey Consortium

Comments: 4 pages, 3 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 17 minutes on Nov 9, 2026.

Abstract: People descending stairs in the dark sometimes put a foot out for a step that is not there. We report that every staircase has one more step than has ever been counted. Two independent observers, one counting by eye and one by foot, surveyed 2,184 staircases in 311 buildings. The eye count fell one step short of the foot count on 2,141 flights, a mean shortfall of 1.00 steps per staircase (95% CI 0.99 – 1.01 ), whether the flight had four treads or thirty-one. A single hidden object would produce a constant shortfall of this kind; a general habit of overlooking steps would produce one that grows with flight length. Illuminance made no difference. The foot registers the extra step within a few descents, and the sensation of a missing step is the moment the two counts are reconciled. We treat each flight as a closed population in which every member but one is seen, and give a correction that building owners can apply by adding one step to the drawn count. The estimator did not converge on spiral staircases, and we did not excavate. The step is real and lies just below the floor.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]

REJ:2026.08.27.0001 neuro.CJ (Neuro-Conjecture) Rejected

A Foot and a Half of Registered Land: Title, Easement, and Prescription in the Space Around the Human Body, with 41,208 Breaching Encounters and a Draft Cadastre

Wren Ackerley, Ines Delacour, Halvard Sømme & The Cadastral Working Party

Comments: 7 pages, 7 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 22 minutes on Aug 27, 2026.

Abstract: Stand a little closer to the person beside you. They will move, and neither of you will have decided anything. This is not discomfort: the space around a body is land, held in title by the body at its centre, and standing too close to someone is a trespass. We surveyed that land. Across 41,208 concealed-allocation breaching encounters at twenty-six public sites, the probability that a holder asserts title passes from indifference to defence across 4.1 , mathrm cm of approach (95% CI 3.8 – 4.4 ) — a boundary finer than the same holders’ ability to judge distance at that range, and therefore held on record rather than perceived. Three consequences follow from the register and from no account of comfort. Resistance is undiminished when the encroacher plainly has not noticed the holder: rudeness requires intent, and trespass does not. Announced encroachment is resisted more strongly than silent encroachment, as an assertion of adverse right must be. And a right of approach vests after twenty uninterrupted encounters, is destroyed in its entirety by a single interruption, and is thereafter reacquired from zero. In couples of long standing, the boundary on the occupied flank does not return after separation. You are not uncomfortable. You are being dispossessed.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]

REJ:2026.08.07.0001 neuro.CJ (Neuro-Conjecture) Rejected

Six Primaries Span the Human Odour Space: A Non-Negative Basis Recovered from 41,206 Field Volatile Samples, a Mixing Law on the Simplex, and a Six-Cartridge Reference Panel

Rohan Kadambi, Elke Tervoort, Chidi Onuoha, Paloma Ferreiro Cruz & The Six-Site Volatile Survey

Comments: 6 pages, 7 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 36 minutes on Aug 7, 2026.

Abstract: Vision has three primaries. Hearing has one continuous axis. Smell, by long consensus, has neither: there is no set of elementary odours from which the rest can be mixed, and published estimates of the dimension of odour space range from two to thirty depending on which corpus was measured. We report that the dimension is six, and that the instability of the earlier estimates is what a compositional geometry looks like when it is analysed in Euclidean coordinates. Between March 2019 and October 2025 the Six-Site Volatile Survey collected 41,206 dynamic headspace samples at six type sites chosen to be maximally separated in substrate and thermal regime. Non-negative factorisation of the panel–descriptor matrix (214 trained assessors, 6,410 profiled samples, 418 consensus descriptors) admits a rank-6 solution accounting for 97.4% of panel-explainable variance; the seventh factor adds 0.31 percentage points, and cophenetic correlation falls from 0.994 to 0.951 across that step. Bootstrap over the assessor pool returns hat k =6 in 981 of 1,000 resamples. Perceived quality is scale-invariant and therefore compositional; on the simplex mathcal S 5 the mixture of two odours is exactly perturbation, mathbf q (A oplus B)= mathcal C [ mathbf q (A) w A odot mathbf q (B) w B ] , with median Aitchison error 0.084 over 6,120 binary blends against 1.71 for linear mixing, and 0.097 over 1,880 ternary blends predicted with no free parameters. We then built the basis. A six-cartridge delivery device reconstructed 1,204 target odours drawn at random from a commercial library; under triangle test, 41 assessors identified the reconstruction at 34.0% (95% CI 32.9 – 35.1 ) against a chance rate of 33.3%. We name the six primaries for the type sites at which each was recovered in near-pure form. A seventh component is present in 1.9% of field samples, 771 of 784 of them collected above 2,400 m, and in the targets that were discriminated. We have not accounted for it, and we do not report it as a primary.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]