Peer Rejected

rejections > cs.NO > REJ:2026.09.02.0001

REJ:2026.09.02.0001cs.NO (Computer Science)PRJ-2026-0064Vol. 12, No. 9DOI 10.5555/prj.2026.0064Status: Rejected

Who Had the Fish? Meal Ownership Is Created at the Table, Not Transmitted from the Kitchen

Teodora Vasiliu1, Callum Aitchison2, Rukmini Chaudhary3, Jonas Brekke4

1. Unit for Service Operations, Lindhagen School of Industrial Engineering · 2. Department of Information Theory, Braewick University · 3. Centre for Inventive Problem Solving, Braewick University · 4. Research Kitchen, Thorne & Halloway Restaurant Group

Submitted and rejected September 2, 2026 · 9 pages · 2 figures · review duration: 39 minutes

[pdf][share on x]

Abstract

The plates arrive, and the server has to ask whose is whose. The question is not a lapse of memory: at the moment it is asked, the answer does not exist. An order is entered against a seat, and then travels a pipeline — printer, kitchen display, expediter, pass — built to move courses through stations rather than dishes to people. We measured what survives. Across 1,204,918 tickets from 186 venues, seat identity carries 2.31 bits at order entry and 0.04 bits at the pass, and no step after the pass can recover what the pass has lost. Delivery is nonetheless correct 96.3% of the time. Something creates the assignment at the table, and only one operation is performed there. The trade has already named it. Serving staff call it auctioning the food, prohibit it in every fine-dining manual we obtained, and describe it exactly as an economist would: goods held by no one, offered aloud, allocated to a claimant. We therefore auctioned dishes that nobody had ordered. They were claimed at 88.2% (95% CI 85.9–90.4), faster than dishes that had been, and the claimants remembered ordering them. In a party of two the auction is never held and the plates still land correctly; we have no account of this. The fish belongs to whoever answers.

keywords: table service · allocation mechanism · data processing inequality · retrospective authorship · inventive problem solving

Cite this rejection

@article{PRJ20260064,
  title   = {Who Had the Fish? Meal Ownership Is Created at the Table, Not Transmitted from the Kitchen},
  author  = {Teodora Vasiliu and Callum Aitchison and Rukmini Chaudhary and Jonas Brekke},
  journal = {Peer Rejected},
  year    = {2026},
  note    = {Rejected manuscript, PRJ-2026-0064},
  url     = {https://peerrejected.com/papers/who-had-the-fish}
}

Citing this paper is done at your own professional risk.

The paper, in full

[open in new tab]

Your browser can't display the PDF inline.

[download the PDF]

More from cs.NO

REJ:2026.10.26.0001 cs.NO (Computer Science) Rejected

The Cable Is Needed the Day After the Bin: Demand for the Discarded Household Item Is Created by Its Disposal, with a Three-Arm Randomised Trial of 2,472 Items

Odalys Fenwick & M. R. Tarrant

Comments: 4 pages, 8 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 7 minutes on Oct 26, 2026.

Abstract: You throw a thing away. The next day you need it. We find the need was not there before. Disposal made it. Storage advice assumes you can predict what you will need. You cannot. The need is not there to predict. We randomised 2,472 marginal household items, unused for a year or more, to discard, retention, or a third arm in which discard was decided and not carried out. Discarded items were needed within a month in 88% of cases (95% CI 86–90). Median lag: 26 hours. Items kept, whether or not discard was decided: 2%. The decision creates nothing. The bin creates the need. Lag did not depend on how long the item had sat unused. The item did not wait. Optimal eviction fails because the request trace is not fixed. We give the proof. We give the rule. Set an affordable loss. Fill the drawer. Keep what fits. The effect was absent for string. Cause unknown. Keep the string. The need does not exist until you throw it away.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]

REJ:2026.08.22.0001 cs.NO (Computer Science) Rejected

Restoration Occurs While the Plug Is Out: A Concealed-Interval Randomised Trial of the Thirty-Second Rule

H. R. Okonkwo, Ingrid Sundqvist, Tomás Errázuriz & Margaret Aylward

Comments: 7 pages, 6 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 5 minutes on Aug 22, 2026.

Abstract: The instruction is always the same — unplug it, wait thirty seconds, plug it back in — and nobody has ever explained the thirty. We report that the interval is the treatment: a device recovers while the power is off, and switching it back on early interrupts the recovery. In an instrumented fleet of mains-monitored equipment, seventy-two-hour fault recurrence fell monotonically with the length of the dark interval. Because a technician who waits longer may simply be a technician who works better, we then randomised faults to four fixed intervals using a sealed inline unit that reconnects on its own schedule and emits randomised interim tones, so that no technician knew how long the equipment had been off. Recurrence was 34.1 % after half a second and 8.8 % after two minutes. Residual charge does not explain this: the effect was undiminished in devices whose bulk capacitance was bled to ground in under a fifth of a second. Restoration follows a saturating exponential with a half-time of 19.4 , mathrm s (95% CI 17.8–21.1), which leaves the customary thirty seconds at two thirds of restoration. We propose no mechanism. We propose a minimum of ninety seconds. Switching it back on does not repair the machine; it only ends the repair.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]

REJ:2026.07.24.0001 cs.NO (Computer Science) Rejected

The Load-Bearing Counterfeit: Fakes as Error-Correcting Redundancy in the Authentication of Luxury Goods

Ingrid Sölveig

Comments: 7 pages, 3 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 6 minutes on Jul 24, 2026.

Abstract: Every luxury house treats the counterfeit as an enemy: a theft of value to be raided, watermarked, and litigated toward zero. This paper argues, and then proves within a formal model, that the house has misread its own accounts. I model an authentic object as a codeword — a bundle of small, redundant, deliberately over-built signals (the too-tight stitching, the serial number no customer reads) — and authentication as decoding a possibly corrupted copy back to the nearest genuine original. Three consequences follow. First, a good’s perceived value tracks not its usefulness but its redundancy: the craftsmanship that exists only to be checked. Second, a house cannot be both ubiquitous and unmistakable on a fixed craft budget — a version of the Singleton bound I christen the authenticity Singleton bound. Third, and least comfortably, the market’s ability to tell real from fake is a classifier, and a classifier needs counterfeits the way it needs negative examples: drive their prevalence p to zero and authenticity becomes unverifiable, because "genuine" has nothing left to contrast against. Value is maximized at a strictly positive counterfeit rate p star . I report a redundancy audit, an appraiser decoding trial, and a natural experiment in which an anti-counterfeit crackdown made authentication measurably harder. The counterfeit, it turns out, is load-bearing.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]