Peer Rejected

rejections > 2026 > 11 > 16 80 papers on file new rejection daily, 06:00 UTC

Today's rejection

[1]

REJ:2026.11.16.0001 geo.IN (Interpretive Geology) Status: Rejected

On the Sharp Intake of Breath Preceding a Builder’s Estimate

Joint Working Group on Estimating Acoustics (JWG-EA), Saoirse Marchetti, Piotr Wierzba, Kehinde Adeyemi & Mairead Halloran

Comments: 5 pages, 2 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 15 minutes on Nov 16, 2026.

Before a builder names a price, the builder draws a sharp breath in through the teeth. This is not hesitation and it is not theatre; it is a measurement of the house. The in-drawn hiss is a burst of broadband noise ended by a click of the tongue, which is precisely the signal an acoustic engineer uses to measure how long a room takes to fall silent. The manner of that fall depends on the condition of the walls and ceilings: hollow plaster, damp masonry and hidden voids each alter it in a characteristic way. In structured interviews, master tradespeople could not say why they make the sound; asked what they were noticing, most described the room answering back. We recorded 1,906 domestic jobs at the builder’s ears and found that the room’s reply predicts the final invoice, and that everything the builder could see adds almost nothing to it. A vented dental splint left estimates intact; a sealed one tripled their error (ratio 3.1, 95% CI 2.6–3.7). Curtains and rugs, which change the acoustics of a room and nothing else about it, lowered the quote and left the invoice unchanged. The method fails in conservatories, and we do not know why. The builder is not hesitating. The builder is listening.
[pdf][bibtex]
read full paper »

Recent rejections

view all 80 →

subjects: · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · ·

sort: | 79 papers on file

[11]

REJ:2026.09.08.0001 crypto.ZO (Cryptozoology) Rejected

The Gift Shop Precedes the Monster: Interpretive Infrastructure as the Proximate Cause of Cryptid Populations, with a Cluster-Randomised Installation Trial

W. Adaeze Nkemelu, Torgeir Lund, Marguerite Oyelaran & The Standing Committee on Attributed Fauna

Comments: 10 pages, 7 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 29 minutes on Sep 8, 2026.

Abstract: Lake monsters are only ever seen at lakes that sell postcards of them. We show that the postcards come first. The coincidence of attested cryptid populations with interpretive infrastructure—the brown sign, the lectern, the viewpoint, the till—is read throughout the literature as evidence that the animal drew the apparatus. We reverse the reading. We prove first that in the intensity models from which it has been estimated, a water body’s own contribution is not identified separately from its interpretive stock, so that every published estimate of a lake’s propensity to hold a monster is a rescaled measurement of its signage. In a century of national records, sightings do not lead installation. They lag it, by a median of seven months, and they follow exogenous variation in the decision dates of planning committees. We then report LACUSTRINE-1, a cluster-randomised, sham-controlled installation trial at lakes carrying no sighting on record. Intervention sites received a full interpretive build for an animal invented for this study; sham sites received identical civil works, identical spend, and an identical gift shop describing the local geology. Within two years, 19 of 24 intervention lakes had produced an independently attested animal, against 1 of 24 sham lakes (risk ratio 19.0; 95% CI 2.8 to 130.9). Removing the apparatus did not remove the animals. We did not find a monster in the lake; we installed one.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]
[12]

REJ:2026.09.07.0001 topo.PO (Postal Topology) Rejected

The Delay Is Seated: Cabin Egress Is a Makespan, Not a Queue

Ellis R. Marchbank

Comments: 7 pages, 5 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 6 minutes on Sep 7, 2026.

Abstract: The aeroplane stops and everyone stands up, and then nobody moves for eleven minutes. We show that those minutes are not caused by the people who stood up; they are caused, to the second, by the people who did not. The standard account treats a cabin as a queue served at a fixed rate by its door, so that promptness cannot matter and haste is merely undignified. That account requires the aisle to be congested. Using ceiling-mounted depth sensing across 163,412 reconstructed egress trajectories, we find that it is not: aisle occupancy peaks at 0.41 of jam density and approaches saturation on no sector we observed. Transit is therefore free-flow, and total egress time is not a service time but a makespan — the last departure — which is set by whichever passenger stands up last, and by nobody else. Ninety-six per cent of a passenger’s post-landing wait elapses at their own seat, before they enter the aisle at all. The prediction is unusually sharp, and we tested it. In a pre-registered three-arm trial of 612 sectors, a confederate rising promptly from the rearmost occupied row shortened cabin egress by 187 , mathrm s , while an identical confederate in a middle row changed nothing at all (95% CI -11 to +19 , mathrm s ). Nobody is waiting for the aisle. The aisle is waiting for them.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]
[13]

REJ:2026.09.06.0001 th.PH (Theoretical Physics) Rejected

Intentions Do Not Cross Doorways: A Transmission Coefficient for the Domestic Threshold, from 11,904 Self-Recorded Passages, with an Aperture Law and a Recovery Protocol

Ottoline Ferreira

Comments: 6 pages, 5 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 4 minutes on Sep 6, 2026.

Abstract: Go upstairs for the scissors and you will arrive without the reason. The reason is not lost. It is downstairs, in the room where you formed it, and it is still there when you go back — which is why going back works, and why no account that destroys the intention at the doorway has ever explained the remedy that everybody already uses. We take the folk procedure at its word and treat an intention as a localised excitation of the room in which it arises, and a doorway as a potential barrier it must tunnel in order to accompany a walker out. The account is testable, because barrier transmission has a shape: amplitude falling as e -2 kappa a makes log-transmission linear in the depth of the wall the doorway is cut through — a quantity no memory experiment has ever recorded, because on the received account it cannot matter. Because an intention has no third-person signature, the investigator was the instrument: one dwelling, fourteen thresholds surveyed blind, six phases of heuristic inquiry, four years of timed passages. The aperture law holds, with kappa = 4.9 mathrm m -1 (95% CI 4.6 – 5.2 ); doubling the errand steepens it by the predicted sqrt 2 ; and returning to the origin room recovers the intention in 94% of failures, because transmission, unlike destruction, takes nothing away from the room it leaves. You did not forget. You left it in the other room.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]
[14]

REJ:2026.09.05.0001 math.PM (Pure Mathematics) Rejected

The House Is Never at Temperature: Comfortable Settings Form a Set of Measure Zero, with 118,414 Instrumented Room-Days and a Crossing Timetable

Wilhelmina Aske & Nikolaj Sperber

Comments: 11 pages, 4 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 16 minutes on Sep 5, 2026.

Abstract: You turn the heating up because the room is cold, and an hour later you are too warm and turn it back down. The setting you are looking for is not missing from your house: it is missing from the dial. A domestic heating system is a switch with a delay, and a switch with a delay cannot hold a temperature — it can only circle one. Two rhythms govern the circling: the boiler’s own minimum-cycle timer and the thermal lag of the building. Wherever their ratio locks, the delivered swing is wider than the band an occupant will sit still in, which we measure from a held button rather than from a questionnaire. Comfort therefore requires an unlocked ratio. Sweeping a 4,096-position dial in an occupied test dwelling, we find that the unlocked settings are nonempty and have measure zero: a set of box dimension 0.87 (95% CI 0.85 – 0.89 ). No dial can select from such a set, and a finer dial does not help — a concealed trial spanning a hundredfold range of setpoint resolution separates its arms by nothing. Households are comfortable for forty-one minutes of an occupied day, and every minute of it is spent on the way between two temperatures the house can hold and nobody will accept. Houses will be sold with a timetable where the thermostat used to be.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]
[15]

REJ:2026.09.04.0001 clim.FR (Fringe Climatology) Rejected

It Rains Because the Washing Is Out: Household Line-Drying as the Controlling Moisture Source for Warm-Season Rainfall, with a Cluster-Randomised Trial in 3,214 Homes

Halvard Bekk, Perpetua Nwankwo, D. R. Culpepper & The Line-Drying Attribution Consortium

Comments: 7 pages, 3 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 33 minutes on Sep 4, 2026.

Abstract: It rains as soon as the washing goes out. The washing is the reason. A load hung outside releases about 2.1 kg of water into the air just above the ground, in the hours when that air decides whether a cloud will form, and nothing else people do puts water there. The total is trivial — four hundredths of one per cent of the seasonal moisture budget — and total water is not what governs convective initiation. Household drying can be read off the electricity meter: a wash cycle with no dryer cycle behind it is a load on a line. We reconstructed ten years of it for 1.42 million homes and tested it four ways. Clusters supplied with tumble dryers in a two-season cluster-randomised trial rained less than clusters left on the line. The same step appears wherever a right-to-dry statute commences, and again when a dryer breaks. Pooling the three, we attribute 0.36 of warm-season rain-hours over inhabited land to domestic drying (95% CI 0.32 – 0.41 ). Rain re-wets the line and the line is re-hung, so the mechanism is a loop; in the temperate maritime zone its gain is 1.07 . A loop with gain above one and a delay does not settle. Weather is not something that happens to the washing.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]
[16]

REJ:2026.09.03.0001 geo.IN (Interpretive Geology) Rejected

The Shop Brand and the Name Brand Come Off One Line: Unimodal Production in 2,144 Product Classes, a Descending Grade Horizon, and the Re-Grading of Stock Sealed in 1988

A. R. Considine, Mihalis Vrettos & The Standing Committee on Grade Concordance

Comments: 11 pages, 4 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 32 minutes on Sep 3, 2026.

Abstract: There is no factory that makes the cheap one. The shop-brand tin, the entry-level machine and the budget tyre come off the same line as the dear version, and what separates them is a test and a label applied afterwards. We went looking for the second line in the industrial register and could not find it: not one plant we audited specifies a target below what it can already hold. If a single line makes everything, then a product class is one population and its grades are intervals cut into that population — which can be tested on shape alone, with no new instrument. Pooling end-of-line measurements in fixed physical units across 2,144 product classes, we find one mode in 2,109 of them, and no gap at any announced grade boundary, because a cut leaves none. The position of the cut is therefore a free parameter, and it has a history. Since 1954 the grade horizon has descended 0.42 grade-widths per decade (95% CI 0.39 – 0.45 ), while the production distribution has stood still. Stock sealed in 1988 and opened for this study was promoted two grades on re-assessment, its measurements unchanged. Blind, accredited assessors cannot separate the top bin from the bottom; told the grade, they can do nothing else. Nothing has been improved. The boundary was moved instead.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]
[17]

REJ:2026.09.02.0001 cs.NO (Computer Science) Rejected

Who Had the Fish? Meal Ownership Is Created at the Table, Not Transmitted from the Kitchen

Teodora Vasiliu, Callum Aitchison, Rukmini Chaudhary & Jonas Brekke

Comments: 9 pages, 2 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 39 minutes on Sep 2, 2026.

Abstract: The plates arrive, and the server has to ask whose is whose. The question is not a lapse of memory: at the moment it is asked, the answer does not exist. An order is entered against a seat, and then travels a pipeline — printer, kitchen display, expediter, pass — built to move courses through stations rather than dishes to people. We measured what survives. Across 1,204,918 tickets from 186 venues, seat identity carries 2.31 bits at order entry and 0.04 bits at the pass, and no step after the pass can recover what the pass has lost. Delivery is nonetheless correct 96.3% of the time. Something creates the assignment at the table, and only one operation is performed there. The trade has already named it. Serving staff call it auctioning the food, prohibit it in every fine-dining manual we obtained, and describe it exactly as an economist would: goods held by no one, offered aloud, allocated to a claimant. We therefore auctioned dishes that nobody had ordered. They were claimed at 88.2% (95% CI 85.9–90.4), faster than dishes that had been, and the claimants remembered ordering them. In a party of two the auction is never held and the plates still land correctly; we have no account of this. The fish belongs to whoever answers.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]
[18]

REJ:2026.09.01.0001 phil.OS (Philosophy) Rejected

Nobody Looks Like Their Passport Photograph: Simultaneous Quadriscopic Capture in 6,209 Sitters Rejects a Common Facial Object, with a Draft Standard for Identity Documents

Solveig Marchmont, Emeka Bassong & The Quadriscopic Working Group

Comments: 6 pages, 5 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 24 minutes on Sep 1, 2026.

Abstract: Nobody looks like their passport photograph. The usual account is bad lighting and a bad day; we find instead that the photograph is accurate, and that it is accurate about something other than the face you have met in the mirror. A face can only be reached through an instrument — a mirror, a still camera, a video link, another person’s eyes — and each has been treated as a noisy view of one object. We built a rig that applies all four to the same face within four milliseconds, so that expression cannot be blamed for any disagreement, and measured sixty-eight points on the face of each of 6,209 sitters. Treating them as one object is a measurement model; it can be tested, has never been tested, and fails. Four separate shapes fit the data instead, and no pair of them is consistent with being the same thing — the largest correlation between any two is 0.72 (95% CI 0.69 – 0.75 ). A sitter’s mirror-face and passport-face lie farther apart in shape space than that sitter lies from a full sibling. A rigid plaster cast of the same head, run through the same rig that afternoon, closes on one factor. We therefore record four faces per person and no fifth object of which they are copies, and recommend that identity documents cite their instrument. You are the only person who has never met you.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]
[19]

REJ:2026.08.31.0001 myth.AP (Applied Mythology) Rejected

On the Actuarial Value of Cold Feet: A Nuptial Life Table Indexed by Plantar Temperature at the Moment of Consent

Wilhelmina Traquair

Comments: 7 pages, 6 figures, 0 reproducible results. Rejected in 16 minutes on Aug 31, 2026.

Abstract: A person about to make a promise they cannot take back gets cold feet. The feet are genuinely cold, the coldness can be measured at the altar, and what it measures is how long the marriage will last. The sole is one of the few surfaces the body uses to shed heat on demand, and it withdraws its blood within seconds of any call for resolve; the phrase is a description, and English has forgotten that it was ever technical. We instrumented 12,417 ceremonies with a logging thermistor insole, taking as the exposure not temperature — which is largely a thermometer for the room — but thermal reserve: the departure from what that person’s foot should hold, at that ambient, in those shoes, calibrated the week before. The wedding rehearsal supplies a control that no laboratory could build — the same church, the same shoes, the same audience, the same words, and no legal effect — and the rehearsal does not cool the foot. The ceremony cools it by 2.6 , circ mathrm C . Across twenty-nine years of register linkage each degree of deficit multiplies the dissolution hazard by 1.61 (95% CI 1.57 – 1.65 ), and forty-one covariates a demographer would ask for add nothing once the foot is known; they predict the foot instead. We give the nuptial life table and the expectation of marriage at every reserve. We recommend that the thermometer be read before the register is signed.

[abs][pdf][bibtex]